The Ins and Outs of the St. Kilda Scandal
By Matt Marsden on Tue, 21/12.2010As various news outlets have reported around the clock for the past day, superstar captain of the St. Kilda Football Club Nick Riewoldt and skilled on-baller Nick Dal Santo have been embroiled in the middle of a nude photos scandal. Nineteen year old model Kim Duthie, an alleged friend of Riewoldt though Riewoldt denies knowing her, and Dal Santo's teammate Sam Gilbert, released the images of the star Saints in provocative positions on her Facebook page.
In a conference scheduled by Riewoldt himself he denied knowing anything about the existence of the photographs.
"The photograph was taken over twelve months ago in Miami by a teammate, Sam Gilbert. I asked Sam to delete the photo and it was my understanding that it was deleted.
"To infer that I would stand there and pose for a photograph naked knowing that it was going to be kept is just absolute garbage and offensive that people would think that."
The point that Riewoldt is trying to argue is that it is not his fault that the images have surfaced as he believed them to be deleted. However, he is not to play the innocent role in this situation. It seems as though he is dishing the issue off onto Sam Gilbert's shoulders, as Gilbert was allegedly the one who didn't dispose of the images yet is supposedly the source of the images. Do Riewoldt and Dal Santo deserve to have this happen to them? Not at all but it's an issue that could have easily have been avoided with any semblance of common sense.
Players of the AFL need to finally realise that what they do, no matter when during their career, will be scrutinised. The fact of the matter is that they are not regular human beings as soon as they pull on the guernsey for the first time. We hear it time and time again but the players never seem to learn.
With that said, what Kim Duthie is doing to these players is inhumane. Sure, these people are celebrities, but that doesn't mean that using their own star status against them is just. She knew before she released the images that there would be a huge backlash, and to use that as a weapon against Riewoldt and Dal Santo is deceptive, cruel and sickening.
Let's not forget that Duthie also claimed that she had become pregnant with twins to a St. Kilda player before this year's season. Sounds to me like she has a chip on her shoulder and has everything that's coming to her.
It is believed that Duthie's actions are inspired by the way she was treated by the players in question as well as one of their managers. In a radio interview with radio station 3AW, she confirmed that she had more images saved for a rainy day.
"I have twenty-one (images) all together, three of them are of different Saints players and the rest are from different AFL clubs."
Every sign that Kim Duthie has given leads to a simple conclusion - she wants payback and attention. That's it. Her actions are a reflection of her immaturity. If she feels that it is her duty to get revenge on the players in question instead of being rational and contacting the right people, instead of throwing everything in the air and acting out like a spoiled brat, then best of luck to her. She is only digging her own hole deeper. Not many people out there are interested in hiring someone so deceptive, so her modelling career might be on the skids. What company will want to have a model that gives a negative impression everytime they are viewed advertising their product?
As for Nick Riewoldt and Nick Dal Santo, if you're stupid enough to stand there and have a mate take nude pictures of you, you need to be ready to suffer the concequences of your actions. A fire doesn't start without a spark. As a role model, not only to society but to your football club, you need to be smarter with your actions. By all means, have fun in your spare time, but it's not hard to have fun and still be aware of what you're doing.

Join to follow

She is actually 17! I think
She is actually 17! I think its disgusting and she will be at the fate of the federal court. Defamation at the least! A gross invasion of privacy by a juvenile delinquent who obviously needs a good smack!
Kimberley Duthie is 17 years
Kimberley Duthie is 17 years old and comes from a family with a history of serious mental illness (on her mother's side).
I am led to believe that she
I am led to believe that she is nineteen years old.
According to her athletics
According to her athletics results freely avbl online, she is most definitely under-18.
give her a education, she
give her a education, she whored herself all the way, used herself up know she feels neglected, dead set problem child with a lot to learn. And for fuck sake to all footballers you tight asses get top dollar hookers
Matt Marsden, how much were
Matt Marsden, how much were you paid to write this? You clearly think that it is all her fault! Pathetic. I hope you and those like you eventually get what's coming to them.
Please educate yourself about
Please educate yourself about psychopathy, because Kim Duthie fits the profile of a manipulative psychopath.
The media has to blackban
The media has to blackban her. She's only doing this for attention & while the media keeps giving her publicity, they are playing into her hands. If they ignore her, she'll go away. And she does seem to have been 17 for a long time. I suspect she is 19 & is playing on the "under 18-thing"... sick men's fetish for schoolgirls..
Her FB profile is digusting, demeans all women & the comments from some of the sick men, shows what kind of creeps there are out there. She claims on her FB profile to have been "Clubbing" since she was 14. In WA photo ID is req'd at night clubs, who does she sleep with in Vic to get into clubs at 14?
But at the same time, the players should have the sense to stay away from her. No woman would want to go near any man who has touched her.
They are all to blame. The brainless twits who chase footballers, & the moronic players who don't have the common sense to stay away from them. They deserve each other.
I also want to know what she lives on... if it's Newstart Allowance, as a tax payer I am supporting her. If journalists are paying her for photos & stories, they should be sacked. She is unemployable, who'd agree to work alongside her & risk being the subject of her next "story". She's a whore. And football players need to use the brain in their heads occassionally.
Nice to see that an article
Nice to see that an article written months is being well received at the moment. ;)
I find this all very
I find this all very interesting. Obviously, there are so many issues surrounding this and rights and wrongs.But just wondering when all other media are not allowed to name her why you can name her. Does that make you in breach of the law?
TheBigTip is an opinion
TheBigTip is an opinion forum, not a news outlet. If we were to be in trouble with the law (and the AFL), we would have been contacted by now.
Kim you are a typical stupid
Kim you are a typical stupid young girl.....every parents nightmare....never give out your number to strangers....never consent to underage sex.....you have ignored every decent and respectable piece of important and vital advice ever offered by parents everywhere, your teachers, your piers, your friends and even GOD. You deserve nothing and yet everything....You are a terrible human being...SHAME ON YOU
I just saw this piece of work
I just saw this piece of work on 60 Minutes. Why would high profile players entertain this 'skank' (her own assessment of herself!) She would struggle with grade 3 English and is virtually brain dead. I can't believe someone as dumb as her has pulled this off and gained so much publicity. The media should be ashamed of themselves for giving this idiot the attention she obviously set out to attain through malicious lies and deception. Are there any morals in the media industry?
A complete summary of the 60
A complete summary of the 60 minutes interview and more can be viewed on the link below, for anybody interested.
http://www.thebigtip.com.au/afl/kim-duthie-cant-miss-st-kilda-story
she is a ffuuuuccckkkk
she is a ffuuuuccckkkk hheeeeaaaaddddddddddddddd!
Post new comment